Six shield types offer different durability and defensive effects. Start with the documented acquisition routes below, then compare when each shield's abilities actually trigger.
Obtaining and upgrading shields
Craft a Hylian Shield using the recipe below, or transform an Old Rusty Shield into a Fighter’s Shield with Fairy Water. The Old Rusty Shield has no confirmed normal Survival acquisition route in the reviewed wiki sources; do not assume you can craft or loot it. A Dark Hylian Shield is available as a possible rotating tier-5 Goron merchant offer for two Gold Rupees. See Goron trades for rotation and stock details.
Which shield is right for you?
The durability table compares how long each shield lasts; the effect table explains what happens in combat. For a counterattack, consider Fighter’s Shield. For blocked projectiles, compare the two Mirror Shields. Dark Hylian Shield has a kill-triggered healing chance, not a guaranteed heal on every block.
Shields and durability
| Shield | Durability |
|---|---|
| Old Rusty Shield | 200 |
| Fighter’s Shield | 500 |
| Hylian Shield | 2,000 |
| Dark Hylian Shield | 3,000 |
| Mirror Shield (ALttP) | 700 |
| Mirror Shield (OoT) | 9,000 |
Hylian Shield recipe
D Diamond
M Mysterious Scrap
S Vanilla Shield
I Iron Ingot
Dark Hylian Shield trade
The rotating tier-5 Goron trade can offer a Dark Hylian Shield for two Gold Rupees. Each merchant shows only one offer per tier, so the shield may be absent until stock rotates.
Shield abilities compared
The effect depends on the event: a blocked melee hit, a blocked projectile, or a kill while carrying the shield. These are not guaranteed effects on every block.
| Shield | Special effect | When it happens |
|---|---|---|
| Fighter’s Shield | 25% counterattack roll. The bash deals 2 damage to a living attacker. | Triggered in the shield-block event. |
| Mirror Shield (ALttP) | Reflects a projectile when the blocked damage originates from a Projectile; otherwise it has a 25% counterattack roll against a living attacker. | Projectile branch takes precedence over counterattack. |
| Mirror Shield (OoT) | Attempts to reflect projectile damage by creating a new projectile and sending it along the defender’s look direction. | Requires a valid projectile to clone. |
| Dark Hylian Shield | When you kill a Mob while the shield is in either hand, 30% chance to restore 1 health point if not already at full health. | Kill-triggered; it is not a guaranteed heal on every block. |
| Old Rusty / standard Hylian | No additional triggered effect is asserted from this shield-event handler. | Standard shield behavior and durability still apply. |
Important distinction: Fighter’s Shield and Mirror Shield (ALttP) use chance-based counterattacks against eligible living attackers. Mirror Shield (OoT) uses its separate projectile reflection logic instead. When an effect does not trigger, check the shield, damage type and the relevant chance rather than assuming the shield is broken.